The views expressed in community are solely the opinions of participants, and do not reflect those of What to Expect. Elvie Curve vs Haakaa Silicone Pump Which One Works Better For Collecting Milk During Nursing Session? I've had the diaper genie for 2 years with my son and never have really been happy with it. The diaper bins that hold a weeks worth of diapers stink when u change it, a regular can changed daily is better, I had a diaper genie with my first and it did not hold up well as she got bigger. Just open the lid and remove. The self-sealing system works to prevent odors and it doesnt smell when the Munchkin pail is sealed. This diaper pail uses three approaches to control odors: a self sealing system, special liners and disks that absorb odors. The Arm & Hammer branded option releases a pleasant lavender smell, and lasts for roughly 90 days. First, wrap the diaper into itself, nice and compact. Of course the amount of diaper that fits in the bag depends on the diaper size. Read More, If you're diligent in changing the bag, you shouldn't run into too many problems. Essentially, when you close the lid, the liner bag twists, sealing in smells. This product is rated 4.3 stars out of 5 stars. Please select a reason for escalating this post to the WTE moderators: Connect with our community members by starting a discussion. The front tilt bin makes it easy to change the bag. The Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step both use a foot pedal opening mechanism for easy operation of the diaper pail. Also, they recommend changing them out every 90 days, giving you more time than the carbon filters of the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete. The answer to this question is that they are both compatible with each other, but it is recommended that you use the same brand of diapers as your child's current ones. Generally, Munchkin is more budget-friendly and has been proven to be the No.1 option for odor control. And with a baking soda puck trapping excess smells, your nursery can stay fresher for longer. Are there more budget-friendly choices to consider? This means those nasty odors wont get trapped in the pail. Beyond that, this is a sturdy standby that performs better than more expensive models and will help keep your nursery from smelling less than fresh. Another video for you guys! They arent super expensive, but a busy mom with a newborn doesnt need to be thinking about ordering something like carbon filters for a diaper pail. Performance & security by Cloudflare. The Diaper Genie Complete is an airtight portable pail specially designed to contain the odor of dirty diapers. Then, you can pull down more of the continuous liner and start fresh. Getting diapers through the opening requires some pushing. TJ is the Executive Editor of Reviewed.com. Check Price. think twice before sharing personal details, foster a friendly and supportive environment, remove fake accounts, spam and misinformation, delete posts that violate our community guidelines, reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts. If youve narrowed down your choice to Playtex Diaper Genie Complete vs. Munchkin Step Diaper Pail, my comparison should help you make the final decision. Some require special refills that work specifically with the diaper pail or genie. Made from steel and powder coated so easy to maintain. The Diaper Genie Complete had the strongest pail features of any that we tried, and it comes with a reasonable price tag. Considering I studied physics, engineering (PhD, MSc), I thoroughly research the topics I write about. I honestly would just do the genie its much cheaper and if it stinks just buy a little air freshener that lasts longer than the armor hammer things and put it in the pail, Diaper genies are terrible and break easily, I just threw my two out, this baby will just have a small garbage can that we can change daily. 0 Compare . You might want to read an article I wrote recently about some Diaper Genie alternatives? I'm getting a small pale with a tight fitting lid and changing it more often then a diaper pail. munchkin vs diaper genie coming in a variety of types but also different price range. Xoxo. The Diaper Genie Expressions is just like the Diaper Genie Complete, but if you got rid of the things we liked and kept most of the things we didnt. Learn more about. Required fields are marked *. In general, the Diaper Genie is often cheaper than the Munchkin. Diaper Genie boasts Double Air-Tite clamps that work together with a carbon filter to deter odor build-up. If you are not satisfied with the fit of this refill call 1 (800) 344-2229 or visit www.munchkin.com to learn how to receive a refund. I don't know about the Munchkin, but we have the diaper genie for my son and I don't like it. Everything we recommend Our pick Ubbi Steel Diaper Pail The best diaper pail $70 from. Diaper Genie II Elite, Diaper Genie Essentials and Diaper Genie II pails, Diaper Genie Expressions, and Diaper Genie Complete; Made with 7-layer film; Lavender-scented; error: We aim to show you accurate product information. In this article youll find my diaper pail reviews, based on my own experience. For the ones that use special refill bags and the squeegee push method, you will most likely be greeted with a huge snake of soiled diapers contained within the bags. when i. Bonus: For every pail purchased, Munchkin will plant a tree. Investing in a quality diaper pail is one way to make things easier. I hated our diaper genie!! Hey, what's up, hello?! Atone have a preference on a diaper pail? Your email address will not be published. One drawback to the Playtex Diaper Genie Complete is that it doesn't have a child lock to keep kids from opening it and tossing toys inside or, worse, playing with the soiled diapers. 180 Diapers. Neither of these are very practical, which is why having a quality diaper pail that contains odors well is essential for new parents. It also usually has a special chute that you slide diapers down so they fall toward the bottom of the pail, and that keeps odors locked in. This design is actually very good at sealing in odor so it doesnt affect the roomthough when you empty the bag you're probably going to stink up the joint anyway. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I found out that only these knockoff refills work with Munchkin. Refer to your owner's manual for definitive cleaning . You need to push diapers through the Munchkins mechanism, but they should just fall through the flaps into the Genie. What is better: Diaper Genie or Munchkin? Recommendations are independently chosen by Reviewed's editors. Reviewed's mission is to help you buy the best stuff and get the most out of what you already own. Created by Playtex, the Diaper Genie is an easy-to-use pail with an excellent locking mechanism and a convenient foot pedal. The odor and the plastic piece inside just broke. We both agree: diaper pails are essential for the convenience of disposing of stinky diapers and odor containment. There are quite a few similarities between the Munchkin Step and the Diaper Genie. We have to special order the bags off Amazon. The foot pedal opening mechanism is easy to use. One of the reasons is its superior odor control. The inserts get so expensive, they dont last long at all, and they dont contain the smell. Diaper Pail Showdown: Dkor vs. In fact, it was named as the Best Diaper Pail by The Bump in 2017. This is used to absorb odors and also releases a nice, lavender scent. Free shipping for many products! Our top picks are the two most expensive models, with Munchkin - STEP at around $56 and Ubbi at about $80. Though it doesn't trap odor as well as our top pick, the Ubbi Steel is one of the few options for anyone who doesnt want to get stuck buying expensive, proprietary refill bagsor anyone planning to use cloth diapers. We love this!). When it comes to Munchkin vs Diaper Genie, two very popular brands, which one is better than the other? Note : Not for use with Munchkin Step and Pail Diaper Pails. Buy at Amazon Both diaper pails are compact enough to fit into even smaller baby rooms without getting in the way. IMO they both suck! Tell us a bit more about you so we can get to know each other better. Does your favorite option require special bags? The smell briefly escapes (disappears in minutes) when you open it if its full of poopy diapers. But, I like to try things out & form my own opinion. This hasn't been a big deal for me. Do Munchkin refills work with Diaper Genie. Diaper genie vs munchkin step diaper pail? Although I breast feed my child and her poop and pee doesn't smell at first really. If you really start to notice a smell build up, you can clean a plastic diaper pail with baking soda. Both the Diaper Genie and the Munchkin Step are made of plastic, and can be easily wiped down should the need arise. Its foul. The Diaper Genie is a cheaper system overall than the Munchkin Step. Now, lets look at one of the best diaper pails and Genie alternatives out there: the Munchkin Step pail. When you open it you do have to push the diaper in because as you close it retracts and closes as its way to help conceal odor(thats the only time you get whiff of the smell) but as soon as you close the lid smell is gone. Plus, I've gotten poop on my hands more than once pushing the diaper down, no matter how well it's wrapped, sometimes it's just a big poop and it doesn't work well! Ubbi is the one Ive liked the most of the 3 Ive used/had. The Diaper Genie Complete is a sleek-looking, plastic diaper pail. Like most diaper pails, both of these are an easy hands-free operation and work with a foot pedal. Additionally, the Genie also has built-in antimicrobials to prevent the spread of bacteria. One complaint of the Munchkin pail is that the mechanism that seals in odors makes it hard to get a diaper into the pail. I also like that you can switch out the Munchkins disk less frequently, and save money by using your own baking soda. The Diaper Genie Complete is the best diaper pail we tested. More so if you havent set your nursery up to make the feeding and changing process so much easier. Allison Banfield an experience mom of two, wife, writer, editor, and passionate parenting advocate! Parents love the Diaper Genie for convenience, and the Munchkin Step for excellent odor control. Since its a blog, of course I also write about my personal experiences. Weve all experienced the moment of opening the trash can and getting a sudden whiff of bad air. 14. How do Munchkin vs Diaper Genie refills answer these questions? Specifications Dimensions (Overall): 24.0 Inches (H) x 14.0 Inches (W) x 12 Inches (D) Weight: 12 Pounds Features: Uses Standard Size Liners, Airtight Lid Prevents Odors Maximum capacity: 180 Diapers Material: Plastic Care & Cleaning: Spot or Wipe Clean Warranty: No Applicable Warranty. Simply pull the bag through the pail, and slice and seal when youre ready to toss it away. Seems better made and eliminates most odor (using for my 2 year old now and once on solids the stink definitely gets worse lol) I'm excited and think it will work great for baby. If you make a purchase through these links, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Truthfully, no one wants a smelly nursery. Besides, steel is much nicer to look at. Last update on 2023-03-04 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API. I could care less about some poop on my hands, but that's a nuisance when you have a squirmy kid on a changing table and you're trying to get them dressed again. With the long list of baby gadgets, clothes and accessories you need to buy, you might be wondering if you need a diaper pail. You can find off-brand refills for the Diaper Genie, but it is much harder to find off-brand bags that work with the Munchkin pail. Our writers, editors, and lab technicians obsess over the products we cover to make sure you're confident and satisfied. it operates with an easy-to-use step pedal. They are supposed to make things more convenient with a baby, but there is no hard-and-fast rule that you must have one in your nursery. While its initially more expensive than the Diaper Genie Complete, the design of this diaper pail will save you money in the long term because it uses regular trash bags instead of proprietary liner bagsmaking it our pick for Best Value: With trash bags costing about 10 cents per bag, you'll save upwards of $200 (or more) over the life of the pail. check out Munchkin deodorizers & refills here, ranking of the best Diaper Genie alternatives, Get your Munchkin Step + FREE travel pail here >>, Stokke Steps vs. Tripp Trapp Review & Comparison of Stokke High Chairs. However, when it comes to overall user-friendliness, we think the Diaper Genie comes out on top. They all suck and are pointless. Its not noticeable with a newborn or just 1 to 2 diapers, but when the bag is nearly full its impossible to escape. A plain metal trash can with a lid from Walmart. I've read both great & horrible things about it. The Ubbi Diaper Pail is slightly smaller than the Diaper Genie which is a good 5 inches taller. The self-sealing contraption means there is a tight squeeze to get the soiled diaper into the pail. Playtex Baby Diaper Genie Elite Diaper Pail System with Front Tilt Pail for Easy Diaper Disposal. If the diaper genie smells are simply too bad for one diaper pail deodorizer idea to work, try multiple methods. Create an account or log in to participate. The branded bags are expensive, and over time, this cost can really add up. We use exclusively for poop diapers, and while he is 22 months old and after they are on solids things change in a not pleasant way on that front, I feel like the odor lingers forever! we have a munchkin one. According to many parents Munchkin Step design is better for odor-control, while the Genie always releases a bit of the sticky smell into the room when you open the lid. When youre preparing for your little one, your to buy list might be considerably longer. Cloudflare Ray ID: 7a2e461abedcd3bf >> Munchkin vs. Use of this site is subject to our terms of use and privacy policy. We prefer it over the Munchkin Step as you can easily dispose of diapers. Family!!!!! think twice before sharing personal details, foster a friendly and supportive environment, remove fake accounts, spam and misinformation, delete posts that violate our community guidelines, reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts. Find advice, support and good company (and some stuff just for fun). It's obvious that parents want to choose a pail that holds more diapers. No one wants this to happen when you open a diaper pail, which is why Diaper Genie and Munchkin Step have both taken steps to eliminate the issue. Essentially, when you open the lid, the pail itself stays sealed. Lower the cost of diaper pail bags & buy dial pail refills with Munchkin. Munchkin Arm and Hammer Diaper Pail Snap with Seal and Toss Refill Bags, Holds 180 Diapers, 6 Count. If youre expecting twins or multiples, you might want to consider a pail with a bigger capacity such as the Playtex Diaper Genie Expressions. Are different bags interchangeable? But when the pail is too full, the closing action squishes diapers, creating a literal gust of poop air. These refill bags are the best option for the Munchkin pail systems, proving to be durable and containing odor flawlessly. Nothing keeps smell in. Try it now. I find that the Diaper Genie Complete does a better job than a regular trash can, but, even when the lid isnt open, after a few months of use, the Diaper Genie has a constant unpleasant smell around it. The Munchkin mechanism also twists the bag to prevent odors from escaping. We empty it out 1-2 times a week. A Group Owner is a member that has initiated the creation of a group to connect with other members to share their journey through the same pregnancy & baby stages. It is easy to use: when your bag has reached capacity, just open the door, cut the liner and tie it off. Arm & Hammer cd92007 member January 2014 Had it a week and threw it out! In some, the liners were tough to change; in others, they required you to shove squishy, messy diapers through a trapdoor, or they simply don't absorb odor and stunk up the joint. The Munchkin Step Pail has managed to do great in various roundups conducted by reviewers from highly trusted sources that . Ubbi vs. Group Black's collective includes Essence, The Shade Room and Naturally Curly. The refills last a bit longer than the Diaper Genie ones, so it is a bit cheaper in the long run, but its much more difficult to find Dekor Plus refills in brick-and-mortar stores and there are not as many third-party options. Please whitelist our site to get all the best deals and offers from our partners. While the Diaper Genie is easier to use, the Ubbi's disadvantage is it requires more work to open the lid. Munchkin one works great in concealing odor. They both will stink, literally. While both brands market their own liners, the Ubbi is compatible with any standard trash bag. Our team of product experts thoroughly vet every product we recommend to help you cut through the clutter and find what you need. ), but the Munchkin Step is likely to leave your home smelling better for longer. I was initially going to go with the Munchkin Step, but the Ubbi is not really any more expensive, get to use your own bags, and (hopefully) it will be sturdy enough to last more than one kid. Munchkin Step - Main Differences Capacity Closure Anti-microbial Odor-Absorbing Disks & Filters Special Bags Refill Rings Ease Of Use Safety Blade Material Cost Munchkin Step Review Munchkin Arm & Hammer Disks Odor Control Refill Bags Inserting Diapers Expense Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Review Opening The Lid Carbon Filters Refill Bags . Munchkin Step Diaper Pail Powered by Arm & Hammer Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe Safety 1st Easy Saver Baby Trend Diaper Champ Deluxe Diaper Dkor Plus. Also, the steel locks the stench in and doesn't absorb the smell like plastic containers. Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for Diaper Pail Refill Bags,Fully Compatible with Arm&Hammer Disposal System Seal. Diaper Genie refills are not compatible with Munchkin brand. H0w often you need to empty your diaper pail depends on how many diapers you have in there which depends on the age of your kids, and how many kids you have. Are you one of those parents looking for the best diaper pail and hesitating between Diaper Genie versus Munchkin Step? They also hold just as many diapers (270), all for less cost. This website is using a security service to protect itself from online attacks. Guaranteed to fit or your money back (this refill is guaranteed to fit all diaper Genie pails excluding diaper Genie Twistaway system, as well as guaranteed to fit both the Munchkin Step and Pail diaper pails. Its a little more expensive from the get go but its steel and you can use a regular 13gallon trash bag in it. Read some mixed reviews on both. If compared both or have really liked one please share! Theres no way to avoid the smell of dirt diapers altogether (if only! It comes in four colors pink, grey, while and blue. The Genie pails advertise that they are anti-microbial the pail itself, as well as the liner bags, this helps minimize the spread of germs. If you feel a message or content violates these standards and would like to request its removal please submit the following information and our moderating team will respond shortly. sold separately See the PAIL diaper pail in action. Like PP, I'm looking into the Ubbi this time. The diaper pail promises to prevent lingering odors by locking the diaper, and its smell, away. Diaper Pail Refill For Diaper Genie Pails With Stronger Layers. As the opening is small, sometimes you have to really push the diaper through. Car Seats; Car Accessories For Baby; Travel Strollers; Baby Carriers . It is a step-to-open design requiring only one hand for diaper deposits. How does the Munchkin pail vs the Diaper Genie compare in the odor department? In this Diaper Genie vs Munchkin Step review, we have compared both diaper pails compare, focusing on usability, odor prevention, price, and more so you can find the perfect diaper pail for you and your little one! The Diaper Genie features double clamps to keep the pail tightly closed to prevent odors from escaping. Create an account or log in to participate. The action you just performed triggered the security solution. Playtex Diaper Genie Complete Pail | Amazon $47.99 Diaper Genie's ultimate diaper disposal system controls odors and makes changing your baby's dirty diapers a breeze. Munchkin Fresh Diaper Pail Refills Price Comparison! Baby Travel. The Diaper Genie liners are also fantastic, particularly with the built-in antimicrobial finish, but it is frustrating that non-branded trash bags dont fit in the pail. The recommendations in this guide are based on thorough product and market research by our team of expert product reviewers.